Which midsize used car is best for you?
#1. 2010 Ford Fusion Hybrid
Average Price Paid – $5,136*
MPG – 41 City, 36 Highway
If more space for the family and more money in the gas budget sound like big wins to you, then consider a used 2010 Ford Fusion Hybrid. This smooth-riding hybrid sedan is a crowd favorite, boasting excellent safety scores, a sleek interior, and plenty of room for passengers. The one drawback? The 2010 Ford Fusion Hybrid is short on trunk space, thanks to its battery pack.
Perfect for drivers who value… safety, fuel economy, and the environment.
#2. 2010 Mercury Milan
Average Price Paid – $4,958 – $6,316
MPG – 22 City, 29 Highway
The year 2010 is a good one for used vehicles! The 2010 Mercury Milan offers discerning drivers the athletic handling of a coupe or convertible, but the spacious interior of a family sedan. Unlike the 2010 Ford Fusion Hybrid, the Milan boasts a big trunk, and it’s available in AWD with a V6 engine.
Perfect for drivers who value… excellent safety ratings, attentive handling, and ample cabin space.
#3. 2012 Chevrolet Malibu
Average Price Paid – $7,367 – $9,649
MPG – 22 City, 33 Highway
Can you say “Malibu” without thinking of sunshine and palm trees? We can’t, and that’s one reason we love the 2012 Chevy Malibu. This cheery sedan offers slightly above MPG for its class, as well as quality handling and strong brakes. Drivers love the Malibu’s comfortable and expansive front seats, sleek interior design, and smooth ride.
Perfect for drivers who value… balanced handling, an accommodating interior, and great fuel economy.
#4. 2012 Honda Accord
Average Price Paid – $8,264 – $12,261
MPG – 23 City, 34 Highway
Honda Accords have almost a cult following, and for good reason: they’re amazing, especially the 2012 Honda Accord. Boasting excellent safety scores for its class, spacious seats in the front and back, and agile handling, the Honda Accord is crazy fun to drive for a midsize sedan. The 2012 Accord is also available in a coupe body style.
Perfect for drivers who value… reliability, safety, and fun!
#5. 2014 Toyota Camry Hybrid
Average Price Paid – $13,110 – $14,228
MPG – 43 City, 39 Highway
The Ford Fusion Hybrid and Toyota Camry Hybrid are equal competition for one another. The 2014 Toyota Camry is known for its quiet ride, comfortable passenger space, and strong acceleration. This last feature is especially important, as hybrids generally have a reputation for lackluster, if not wimpy, acceleration. But the 2014 Camry Hybrid? It drives like a gas-only sedan.
Perfect for drivers who value… the zippiness of a sedan, but the fuel economy of a hybrid.
#6: 2015 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid
Average Price Paid – $13,978 – 15,994
MPG – 36 City, 40 Highway
Wowee, does this car have some pep in its step for being a hybrid! The 2015 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid ranks in the middle of the pack when it comes to used midsize cars. It boasts comfortable seats, easy-to-use technology, and solid reliability. What’s more, this used car gets extra points for a a great warranty.
According to U.S. News & World Report, “Hyundai offers a long certified pre-owned warranty, and used models are often thousands of dollars less than comparable Toyota Camry and Honda Accord hybrids.”
Perfect for drivers who value… a snappy driving experience and the peace of mind that comes with a warranty.
#7: 2010 Mazda Mazda6
Average Price Paid – $4,786 – $7,093
MPG – 21 City, 30 Highway
Weren’t sure you could afford a car as stylish as a Mazda? Well, you can! The 2010 Mazda Mazda6 stands out from the crowd. With sleek styling that’s downright sexy, athletic performance, and a spacious trunk, the 2010 Mazda Mazda6 has a lot to be proud of. The only thing critics don’t love? The fuel economy. At 17-21 MPG in the city and 25-30 MPG on the highway, this Mazda’s fuel economy leaves something to be desired, especially compared to the Chevrolet Malibu and Honda Accord.
Perfect for drivers who value… sport performance and sleek styling. Zoom, zoom!
#8: 2014 Kia Optima
Average Price Paid – $10,363 – $16,174
MPG – 23 City, 34 Highway
According to U.S. News & World Reports, this sweet ride has one of the strongest base engines in its class. Tall riders may have trouble in the back seat, but they can hop in the front, can’t they? They’ll have plenty of space! The Optima’s limited backseat headroom is balanced by a nice interior, strong engine, and a smooth ride.
Perfect for drivers who value… a powerful engine at an affordable price.
#9: 2014 Subaru Legacy
Average Price Paid – $11,439 – 16,522
MPG – 18 City, 25 Highway
Love. It’s what makes a Subaru, a Subaru, and we’re in love with this Subaru! With standard all-wheel drive and a spacious cabin, you’ll be ready to hit the mountains anytime Mother Earth calls your name. The 2014 Subaru Legacy is one of the only midsize cars with standard all-wheel drive, which makes it an ideal ride for drivers who live in climates with unpredictable weather, snow, or ice.
Perfect for drivers who value… safety and the ability to confidently drive in rough weather.
#10: 2012 Buick Regal
Average Price Paid – $8,634 – $10,966
MPG – 19 City, 31 Highway
The 2012 Buick Regal has won multiple awards. It was voted the 2012 Best Upscale Midsize Car for the Money and 2012 Best Upscale Midsize Car for Families. What a combination! The 2012 Regal boasts a turbocharged engine, great fuel economy (eAssist model), a stylish interior, and a powerful turbocharged engine. Critics love its graceful design, smooth brakes, and luxury-style amenities for the folks in the front seat.
Perfect for drivers who value… the finer things in life, but for less!
Ready to shop midsize used cars?
The key to getting a good deal is shopping around, whether you’re buying a car, a house, or getting an auto loan! Find the best used car for you with help from U.S. News & World Report. And the best used auto loan? Turn to myAutoloan! Apply online with myAutoloan and compare up to four used car loan offers at once. You’ll choose the best loan for your needs, just like you’ll choose the best car for your needs.
*Average price paid based on 32536 ZIP code