back to articles | April 04, 2023 | Ashlie Lopez

Categories: Useful Automotive Information

How to Choose the Right Auto Insurance Deductible for You

If you are considering getting an auto insurance policy for your car, there are certain aspects that you will need to pay critical attention to. This includes choosing the right auto insurance deductible, which will dictate the potential costs you may face when covering your costs.


If you are considering getting an auto insurance policy for your car, there are certain aspects that you will need to pay critical attention to. This includes choosing the right auto insurance deductible, which will dictate the potential costs you may face when covering your costs. In this article, we will help you choose the right insurance deductible to ensure you can get the best insurance policy. Without further delay, let's dive into it.

What is an auto insurance deductible?

The auto insurance deductible is the dollar amount you will have to pay to cover repair, damages, or replacement costs in the event of an accident. In essence, the insurance company will only cover a chunk of the expenses while you will have to cover the rest. For example, if your total costs rack up to $5000 and the insurance company pays $4000, you will have to pay $1000. The $1000 is your deductible.

The amount of deductible you choose for your policy will dictate the premiums you have to pay. So, if you pay a lower deductible, the insurance premiums will increase as you are choosing to front a lower portion of the total costs from an insurance claim. It is important to note that you must select a separate deductible for the comprehensive and collision coverages. However, depending on your needs, you can keep this at the same amount.

Factors to consider when choosing an auto insurance deductible

So, the question arises: which deductible should you choose? We will look into all the factors so that you can make the right decision. Let's dive in.


It is best to establish a budget when choosing a deductible amount. Your budget will dictate the amount of money you are willing to pay in the form of premiums. You can get a good idea of this from your proof of income that an employer may give you from their paycheck generator. If your budget is lower, you may want to owe a lesser amount in the form of premiums. This is because you will have to pay the premium amount, regardless of whether an accident occurs, in which you can claim for insurance. However, in such a case, you must be prepared to pay a higher upfront cost if an accident occurs or your vehicle gets damaged.

Deductible-Premium Ratio

The deductible-premium ratio refers to the difference between the deductible and premium amounts. Different insurance companies will have different such ratios. As a result, it is best to examine the deductible and premium rates from various companies in the area to determine which one has the best ratio. For example, increasing the deductible from $500 to $1000 may lead to savings of 30% from one company and 35% from another.

However, before you go for the policy that leads to more savings, go through the policy details to ensure there aren't any hidden costs that may reduce your overall savings. Additionally, remember that state rules can differ and affect how the deductible is incorporated into the insurance policy. Therefore, check out your state's insurance division website to better understand the rules and how they may affect your policy.

Driving Record

Your driving record can be a good indication of the deductible that is right for you. If you have a clean driving record and live in a generally safe area, it is best to go for higher deductibles. Since a claim is less likely to occur, you may have more savings. However, if you do not have a clean driving record, go for a lower deductible to face lower out-of-pocket costs in case of a claim. If your area also has more accidents with busy roads and poor road infrastructure, a lower deductible will be even more beneficial for you.

Insurance Company Reputation

It is best to evaluate an insurance company's reputation when choosing a deductible. This will ensure you can have a good experience with them without risk. After all, you will be at a net loss even if you get an excellent deductible-premium rate but cannot get proper compensation due to the company's financial standing. Also, if a company processes your claims late and does not provide a good service, a low deductible-premium ratio may not feel worth it. Hence, make sure the insurance company has a good reputation. You can do this easily by looking at reviews online and asking friends and family.

Furthermore, checking whether the company is licensed in your state by visiting your state's insurance division website is a good idea. You will also be able to look at consumer complaints made against companies, giving you a good indication of their reputation. Consider getting consultation and information from an insurance expert. You can contact our insurance partners and find valuable information on our site,

Wrapping up

When getting an auto insurance policy, the deductible is one of the more essential aspects to consider. The deductible is the amount you must pay out of your pocket if your car gets damaged in an accident. The higher the deductible you pay, the lower the premium amount. If you have a low budget and want to lower the amounts you pay upfront, going for a higher deductible is a good idea. This way, you will only have to pay a higher amount when an accident occurs. The deductible-premium ratios companies offer can also help you see the relative savings you get if you modify the deductible and premium amounts. Your driving record indicates which deductible to get; if you and the area you are in have a good driving record, a higher deductible will be preferable as the chances of a claim occurring will be low. Finally, an insurance company's reputation will indicate the right deductible, as you want to get your policy from a reputable company. This way, they will treat you right and have the financial capability to cover your losses.

We hope this article has been informative and helped you determine the right auto insurance deductible. Thank you for reading!